Arizona Tire & Automotive Center

The bottom line

You’ve built the hard part: a genuinely strong reputation. Between Yelp and the review sites, you’re sitting on well over 150 reviews with real praise for fair prices and honest service — that’s the thing most shops can’t fake, and you have it. You also run a secure, modern website and a full-service shop that handles everything from tires to transmissions. The gaps are all in the free fundamentals, and one of them is costing you right now: your address doesn’t match across the web. Your own website lists one address while Yelp, BBB, Groupon and the directories list another. When Google sees conflicting information, it trusts your listing less and ranks you lower — and a customer who drives to the wrong address is a lost job. Tighten the basics below and your strong reputation will finally pull its full weight in the map results.

What you’re doing well

• A powerful review base. 58 reviews on Yelp and 150+ across platforms, with genuine praise for fair pricing and great service. Social proof most shops can’t match.
• A real, secure website. aztireandautomotive.com is HTTPS and lists your full range of services — ahead of a lot of local shops.
• A true one-stop shop. Tires plus full mechanical work — oil, brakes, AC, alignment, transmission, engine — so you can keep a customer for everything.
• An established Peoria location with consistent weekday hours and years of history in the community.
• Broad directory presence — Yelp, BBB, Groupon, Yellow Pages and more already list you, giving you a foundation to tighten.

What’s costing you customers (in priority order)

1. Your address doesn’t match everywhere. Your website shows one address (on 96th Ave) while Yelp, BBB, Groupon and the directories show another (W Kelton Ln, Ste 304). This is the single most important fix: pick the one correct address and make it identical on Google, your website, Yelp, BBB, Apple Maps and every directory. Mismatches lower your map ranking and send customers to the wrong place.
2. You have more than one phone number floating around. Your site alone lists two. Choose one primary number and make it match everywhere, so Google trusts you and no call gets lost.
3. Confirm and complete your Google Business Profile. Set the correct primary category (e.g. “Tire shop”) with “Auto repair shop” as secondary, load your services, add fresh photos, and confirm your hours — including how Saturday works.
4. Put your reviews to work on Google. Your reputation is strong, but Google reviews are what move the map. Ask every happy customer at checkout, and reply to the reviews you already have — both help you rank.
5. Clarify Saturday. “By appointment only” on weekends can quietly cost you Saturday searchers. Make sure your listing shows exactly when you’re reachable.
6. Small website wins. Fix the address, add one-tap click-to-call, add LocalBusiness schema, and build simple pages for “tire shop Peoria” and “auto repair Peoria” to catch those searches.

How we assessed this: from public sources — your website, Google/Apple listings, Yelp, BBB, Groupon and business directories — on August 30, 2026. We did not log into your Google Business Profile, so the exact star average and the correct primary address/phone are best confirmed inside your account. Review counts (58 on Yelp; 150+ aggregated) reflect what was public at the time. Sureway Marketing · SurewayMarketing.com · 602-492-6970.